Majauskas vs. DeJesus: Which Method Applies When Dividing Complex Financial Assets in a High-Net-Worth New York Divorce?

Pension statement and stock award paperwork on a desk, illustrating Majauskas vs. DeJesus in a New York divorce

Picture a couple who have been married for eighteen years. One spouse joined a large bank seven years before the wedding and is still there. Over that career, the spouse has built up a pension, and every spring a new grant of restricted stock units arrives that vest over the next four years. When the divorce is filed, both assets carry value that was partly earned during the marriage and partly earned outside of it. How a New York court draws that line depends on which of two Court of Appeals decisions applies.

In New York, Majauskas v. Majauskas (1984) is the starting point for pensions earned over a career. DeJesus v. DeJesus (1997) governs stock options, RSUs, executive compensation and similar awards granted during the marriage that vest over a period of time including before, during and after a marriage. Both use a fraction based on time. They start the clock at different points, and they answer different questions.

Why Does New York Need a Formula at All?

Under Domestic Relations Law § 236(B), marital property is property acquired by either spouse during the marriage and before a separation agreement is signed or a divorce action is commenced. A paycheck is easy to place on one side of that line. A pension or an equity award is harder, because it is earned over a stretch of years that may begin before the wedding, end after the commencement date of a divorce, or both. Each formula measures how much of that stretch overlaps with the marriage. (I wrote about the commencement date itself in What Happens to the Money You Earn After You File.)

What Is the Majauskas Formula?

In Majauskas, the Court of Appeals held that pension rights earned during the marriage and before commencement are marital property, even if they have not yet vested or matured. The court approved a time rule that is still used in New York matrimonial practice:

  • Numerator: the months of credited service earned during the marriage, up to the date the divorce action was commenced.
  • Denominator: the total months of credited service when the benefit is paid.
  • The resulting fraction is the marital portion. The non-employee spouse is typically awarded half of that marital portion, although the percentage is ultimately subject to equitable distribution.

Here is a simple example. A spouse retires with 25 years of credited service, and 15 of those years fell during the marriage before the action was filed. The marital fraction is 15/25, or 60 percent. If the other spouse receives half of the marital portion, that spouse is entitled to 30 percent of each pension payment.

The clock in Majauskas starts on the first day of credited service, whenever that falls. Years worked before the wedding and after the commencement of a divorce sit in the denominator and lower the marital share. Because the denominator is often not known until retirement, the payout is usually deferred and carried out through a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) when benefits begin. You can read more about how I approach pensions, 401(k)s and IRAs on my retirement assets page.

What Is the DeJesus Formula?

DeJesus addressed a different problem: stock options and restricted stock granted during the marriage that do not vest until after the divorce action has started. The Court of Appeals recognized that some of these awards are compensation for work already performed, which makes them marital, while others are an incentive to keep the employee working in the future, which makes part of them separate property.

For awards that are incentives for future work, the time rule is:

  • Numerator: the time from the grant date to the date the divorce action was commenced.
  • Denominator: the time from the grant date to the vesting date.

If RSUs are granted 24 months before the action is filed and vest 48 months after the grant, half of that award is marital. Most grants vest in tranches, and each tranche gets its own fraction. My DeJesus calculator runs this math, and my earlier article on the DeJesus formula walks through the factors a court looks at first.

The clock in DeJesus starts at the grant date, not the hire date. And if an award was made for work already done, such as a year-end bonus paid in stock for performance during the marriage, the DeJesus fraction is generally not used at all. In that situation the award is treated as fully marital.

How Do Majauskas and DeJesus Compare Side by Side?

Majauskas DeJesus
Typical assets Defined Benefit Pensions that build over years of employment Stock options, RSUs and similar awards
When the clock starts First day of credited service Grant date
Numerator Service during the marriage, up to commencement Grant date to commencement
Denominator Total credited service Grant date to vesting date
First question to answer How much of the service fell during the marriage? Was the award for past work or an incentive for future work?
How it is usually carried out A QDRO or domestic relations order when benefits are paid Division or offset of the marital shares as they vest; sometimes may need a constructive trust

The Bottom Line

Majauskas and DeJesus both ask how much of an asset was earned during the marriage, and both rely on time to answer it. Applying the wrong one, or starting the clock on the wrong date, can produce a very different result in a high-net-worth divorce. If your spouse’s compensation includes a pension, equity awards, or both, the method question should be settled before settlement numbers are discussed, as part of the broader equitable distribution analysis.

As a New York matrimonial attorney and Certified Divorce Financial Analyst (CDFA), I review plan documents and grant agreements alongside the financial statements so that each asset is measured the right way. If you have questions about how a pension, stock options or RSUs will be divided in your divorce, contact a trust divorce attorney to schedule a consultation.

Let's Work Together