Can a Postnuptial Agreement Be Thrown Out in New York?

A signed postnuptial agreement and a notary stamp on a desk, representing postnup enforceability in New York

A postnup is usually signed at a calm moment: after a liquidity event, after an inheritance, or after a hard stretch the couple worked through together. Years later, in a divorce, one spouse takes it out expecting it to settle everything. The other spouse’s lawyer starts looking for a way around it.

Mostly, postnuptial agreements in New York are enforceable and the Court prefers that couples have come to their own agreements. Yes, in certain situations a New York court can set aside a postnuptial agreement. The most common grounds are a defect in how it was signed and acknowledged, fraud, duress, overreaching and terms that are unconscionable. Postnups are now common and highly recognized.

What makes a postnup valid in New York?

The rule is in New York Domestic Relations Law Section 236(B)(3). An agreement made before or during the marriage is valid and enforceable if it is in writing, subscribed by the parties, and acknowledged or proven in the manner required to entitle a deed to be recorded. In practice, each spouse signs in front of a notary, who completes a proper acknowledgment.

That last step can sound like a formality. New York’s highest court treats it as essential.

Can a missing or defective notarization void a postnup?

It can. In Matisoff v. Dobi, decided in 1997, the Court of Appeals refused to enforce a postnuptial agreement that both spouses had signed because it was never acknowledged. In Galetta v. Galetta, decided in 2013, the court applied the same rule to a prenuptial agreement whose acknowledgment was missing required language. The fact that both people clearly signed did not save either agreement.

If you signed a postnup years ago, have your attorney look at the acknowledgment page before you rely on it.

When can a court set aside a postnup as unfair?

Even a properly signed agreement can be challenged. Spouses owe each other a duty of good faith that strangers negotiating a contract do not, so courts review agreements between them if one party is looking to set aside the agreement. In Christian v. Christian, decided in 1977, the Court of Appeals said a marital agreement can be set aside if it was the product of fraud, duress or overreaching, or if its terms are unconscionable.

The arguments raised most often include:

  • One spouse hid or understated assets, income or debts
  • The agreement was presented as a condition of staying in the marriage, on a deadline, with no real time to review it
  • Only one spouse had a lawyer, or the second lawyer was chosen and paid for by the other spouse
  • The terms leave one spouse with very little after a long marriage

The statute does not require full financial disclosure or a separate lawyer for each spouse. Agreements signed without them, though, are much easier to attack.

What helps a postnup hold up?

When I draft or review a postnup in a high net worth marriage, I look for:

  • A proper acknowledgment for each spouse, with the full certificate language
  • A schedule of assets, income and debts, with values attached
  • Separate counsel for each spouse, chosen and paid for independently
  • Enough time between the first draft and the signing for real review and negotiation
  • Support terms that are defensible today and are likely to stay that way
  • A review after major changes, such as the sale of a business, an inheritance or the birth of a child

If you already have a postnup

Do not wait until a divorce to find out whether yours will hold. A review now, while the marriage is intact, gives you room to fix a defective acknowledgment or update terms that no longer fit your lives. If you are new to the subject, my earlier post on understanding postnuptial agreements in New York covers what these agreements can include.

If you have questions about a postnuptial agreement, whether you are signing one or relying on one, contact an experienced attorney, and take a look at my blog at lisazeiderman.com for more on marital agreements.

The information in this article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a qualified New York divorce attorney regarding your specific circumstances.

Let's Work Together